How Prep Kitchen Achieved a 67% Conversion Rate Increase in Just 90 Days

- PrepKitchen Conversion wins

How Prep Kitchen Achieved a 67% Conversion Rate Increase in Just 90 Days

Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) isn’t just a buzzword—it’s a proven strategy for driving tangible results. Prep Kitchen, a fast-growing meal prep company, faced challenges familiar to many ecommerce businesses: high customer acquisition costs (CPA), low conversion rates, and a churn rate that hindered growth. By adopting a structured, data-driven CRO approach, they transformed their performance, achieving a +130% increase in conversions and significantly reducing churn.

This case study will break down the strategies, tools, and insights that led to these impressive results, and provide actionable takeaways to inspire your own CRO efforts.

Prep Kitchen: Delivering Healthy Meals to Your Door

Industry: Meal Prep & Healthy Food Delivery

Target Audience: Health-conscious individuals looking for convenient meal options to support goals like weight loss and muscle gain.

Prep Kitchen combines fresh, high-quality ingredients with convenience. However, despite a strong product offering, the business was grappling with underperforming conversion rates, rising CPA, and retention challenges.

The Challenge: Breaking Through the Barriers

Like many growing ecommerce brands, Prep Kitchen struggled with:

• High CPA: Inefficient marketing spend was eating into margins.

• Low Conversion Rates: Website visitors weren’t converting into paying customers.

• High Churn: A significant percentage of customers didn’t return, diminishing lifetime value (LTV).

These issues hindered scalability and put pressure on the company’s bottom line. To maintain growth, they needed to convert more visitors into buyers while retaining existing customers.

The Strategy: A Comprehensive, User-Centric CRO Plan

To address these challenges, Prep Kitchen partnered with CRO experts and adopted a multi-faceted approach grounded in behavioral insights and continuous testing.

1. Identifying Friction Points with Data and Feedback

Prep Kitchen began with an in-depth analysis of the customer journey using tools like:

• Google Analytics 4 (GA4): Funnel metrics revealed where users dropped off.

• Hotjar Session Recordings: Showed real user interactions to pinpoint usability issues.

• “Magic Question” Checkout Survey: A single question—“If something nearly stopped you from buying today, what was it?”—yielded a 20% response rate. These responses exposed UX flaws and clarified customer pain points.

Takeaway: Always listen to your users. Combining analytics with qualitative feedback provides a holistic view of what’s working—and what’s not.

2. Refining the Value Proposition

Through customer feedback, the team discovered two primary buyer motivations:

• Muscle gain

• Weight loss

By aligning the product names with these goals, they shifted from generic labels like “High Protein” and “Low Carb” to outcome-focused names like “Muscle Gain Meals” and “Weight Loss Meals.” They also rewrote website copy to reflect customer language, creating a more relatable and engaging experience.

Expert Tip: Speak your customers’ language. Analyze reviews, surveys, and support tickets to uncover how they describe their needs, then mirror that in your marketing.

3. Streamlining the Checkout Process

The checkout process was simplified to remove unnecessary friction:

• Reduced the number of form fields.

• Optimized the funnel for mobile users, who represented a growing segment of traffic.

• Integrated Apple Pay, which immediately boosted conversions by reducing the time and effort required to complete a purchase.

Expert Tip: A cluttered checkout process is one of the top reasons for cart abandonment. Focus on speed, simplicity, and convenience.

4. High-Velocity A/B Testing

Prep Kitchen implemented a strategic A/B testing roadmap to drive continuous improvement:

• Quick Wins First: Initial tests focused on addressing obvious barriers, like checkout friction.

• Custom A/B Testing Tool: The team developed an in-house tool to resolve tracking issues and enable simultaneous testing of non-conflicting elements.

• Biweekly Test Cycles: New tests were rolled out every two weeks, ensuring a steady flow of insights and improvements.

5. Behavioral Nudges and UX Enhancements

• Highlighted scarcity and urgency with messaging like “Limited availability.”

• Applied behavioral design principles such as “lump costs, fragment rewards,” making pricing feel more appealing by emphasizing the benefits of individual items.

The Results: A Record-Breaking Transformation

Prep Kitchen’s data-driven approach yielded exceptional results:

1. Conversion Rates: Increased by 67% in the first 90 days.

2. Churn Rate: Reduced by 30%, enhancing customer retention.

3. Revenue Growth: Covered their annual CRO service fee within the first month.

4. Operational Growth: Boosted revenue allowed the company to hire full-time designers, developers, and email marketing experts.

5. Recognition: Prep Kitchen earned a spot on the UK’s Fastest 50 Growing Companies list.

Key Metrics:

Metric Before After 90 Days % Change

Conversion Rate 3.0% 5.01% +67%

Churn Rate 20% 14% -30%

CPA £50 £35 -30%

Lessons Learned: Insights for Any Business

1. Ask the Right Questions: The “magic question” checkout survey uncovered qualified, actionable insights that transformed the UX.

2. Align Messaging with User Goals: Highlight benefits that resonate with your audience’s motivations.

3. Optimize for Mobile: Mobile users represent a significant and growing market segment. Tailor the experience to their needs.

4. Iterate Quickly: High-velocity A/B testing ensures you don’t miss opportunities to improve.

Take Your Conversion Rates to the Next Level

If Prep Kitchen’s success story resonates with your business goals, it’s time to take action.

‍